Spoiler One Step Forward to the Flower Path | 꽃길까지 앞으로 한 걸음

Who is erich? :0 when is he going to appear exactly?

It's not possible actually. At the time, I think it was explained in the manhwa if Eve were to stay with the duke or anyone reliable rlly while the monster on the other side is rampaging, the mother would still have to sacrifice herself and managed to decrease the amount of monsters, as said in the manhwa. But then if they knew that Eve actually inherited the holy power? No matter how much the duke or anyone reliable tried to protect his daughter, Eve would still be treated as a sacrificial item because of the greedy people and families who lost their loved ones to the monsters. Adding the fact that her mother's sacrifice actually managed to decrease the amount of monsters...

 

I think this is the biggest plot hole in this novel. If no one has figured out that MC has holy powers while she was living as a slave, then why should it become obvious right away when she’s left to a reliable guardian?
Moreover holy power wasn’t inherited previously, so there’s no need to think too much about the child.
And we all know that when she was left alone in the first TL she has become a sacrifice at the end. In this TL MC was still returned to her father and their family doesn’t experience any issues with her holy powers so far. But the father says that if anyone tries to bother them he’ll start a war without any problems.
So what was the point in making a child suffering for so long if in the end she’s either sacrificed or is living without issues with her family? I feel like it all was done only for a touching intro, but in the end it was not justified properly and feels too unnatural and very unbalanced.
The author makes it look like the mother didn’t care about her child and only thought about saving her lover from additional trouble. Even though there wasn’t much trouble that he could have experienced to begin with because he’s too OP. And her daughter had to suffer abuse and even death in her 1st life. Good job, mom! You have helped your lover to have a little less stress by paying with your daughter’s sanity and life.

 

It's not possible actually. At the time, I think it was explained in the manhwa if Eve were to stay with the duke or anyone reliable rlly while the monster on the other side is rampaging, the mother would still have to sacrifice herself and managed to decrease the amount of monsters, as said in the manhwa. But then if they knew that Eve actually inherited the holy power? No matter how much the duke tried to protect his daughter, Eve would still be treated as a sacrificial item because of the greedy people and families who lost their loved ones to the monsters. Adding the fact that her mother's sacrifice actually managed to decrease the amount of monsters. So z

Well... Now that I think about it, it makes sense... So far nothing happened to her in the duke's place and the fact that she have a support from the emperor (the dad's cousin)... Yeah, I think that's actually more than enough to protect Eve...

 

I agree that the mother's reason for not telling the Duke about Eve is a plothole because as we know, she is well-loved and protected by his side. However, I would like to correct, as far as I remember that before Eve was rescued by the Count, the people who enslaved Eve knew that she has holy power. That is why she was abused and it explains why she was wary of people and always asked them if they would take her powers when she first came to the Duke's mansion. They were extracting her holy power.

 

From my understanding bad guys have found out about her holy powers only later in her 1st timeline. So MC’s fear of torture comes from her previous life. She was rescued in the 2nd TL before anyone got a chance to learn about her having powers. She was treated as a simple slave for a while, this is why no one yet is approaching the duke about MC. And it all has happened because her mother didn’t bother to find any reliable guardian to take care of her daughter while she’s away fighting monsters.

 

Spoiler: male lead

erich ludren/loudren who has silver hair and blue eyes, they mention ml's mother is the fl's mother friend so that's why ml's family and evanna's family is close( sorry i just open chapter 60-61 so this is what i read)

 

I think the reigning emperor is the biggest factor in the mom's decision. While the mom was alive, the "Mad Emperor" ruled the empire. The mom must have thought that the moment the Mad Emperor knew that she was pregnant, he would do everything to confine her so he can use the child later even if it's just to serve as a hostage to guarantee the mom's obedience. And the Duke can't possibly resist an assault led by the emperor. The mom might have also wanted to avoid a civil war between the emperor and the duke.

The manwha also hinted that the mom foresaw that Gerrard, a friend of hers and a relative of the duke, would soon be the new emperor. The mom must have been waiting for the change in emperor to bring the MC to the duke but she died before Gerrard became the emperor.

As to why the mom left the MC alone before she went to her death, we still don't know for sure how she died so I'll reserve my judgment for later.

 

I think of another way. Remember mc has the power to reborn the moment she dies? Maybe this power has something to do with her mom. Maybe like eve her mom also had the power to reborn if not she has the power to see the future (the cat dolls that she gave to twin and her daughter). So I think at first she might have given birth in Duke mansion but perhaps her child gets hurt/killed/kidnapped or the Duke's family gets destroyed the reason might be political,the former emperor,greedy nobles or even those priests. She might have born many times to change the ending and at the end she left the dukedom to give birth to her child to change Eve's fate. This might have been the reason why she didn't tell the Duke about her pregnancy. Otherwise how did she know that someone close the her will become the emperor? And she might have did some forbidden spells or anything to change the outcome of her daughter which is why she keeps dying when eve is 2-3 years old and eve got the power of reincarnation.

 

I just read the latest manhwa chapter does anyone who has read the novel knows what will happen to eve? We need spoilers on the novel please.

 

Spoiler: Official manhwa translation

https://tapas.io/series/everythings-coming-up-roses/info

 

She says that everything is the same from her firts life up to the point when she is rescued, meaning she was kidnapped when still a child in her first life for her holy power. In second life it was the same, they were already torturing her extracting her power, when her family found her she had traumas from being tortured for her power from both timelines. In second timeline no one is aproaching the duke because he closed off the duchy and is hiding the fact that she is there.

In the latest chapters of the manhwa a mysterious guy appeared and sent a letter to the duke hinting on who could have been the culprit on mc's kidnapping, so I think that maybe he was the one who turned back time? He seemed extremely sick as well, so he could have exhausted his powers to do so, not sure tho

 

The ml finally got introduce in manhwa

 

I appreciate it if anyone could spoiler about the upcoming chapter 51 because i dont have patients (or patience) to wait for another week ok? I just wann know about that bastard who calling her a sacrifice or something o(╥﹏╥)o

 

Is the story over? Can anyone spoil me the ending.

 

For those confused by the king seen in earlier chapters (where Eve’s power is being taken), he is from a completely different kingdom than the one she lives in. Basically, her enemies are not the empire where her uncle is the emperor (I’m assuming Gerrard is the Duke’s brother), but all of the other kingdoms’ rulers and churches.

He’s the son of a count, and also the child of the people who rescued Eve.

Spoiler: Erich

He is a water elementalist with a weak body. It is also hinted that he is also a regressor. Eve thinks his presence is very comforting.

 

This is going to sound heartless but sorry no there was absolutely no reason for her to leave the dukes estate, also the emperor knew where she was and even visited them so they definitely weren’t safe form any kind of “politics” hell after the mother died the daughter was found rather easily where if she stayed with the duke most if not all the daughters suffering could have been avoided. Sorry but the mom was irredeemably stupid here

 

All in all , I don’t care if the mom didn’t wanna stay with the fiance or friends but it doesn’t make sense to leave for fighting monsters and not trusting the child to anyone and leave her at home alone! And how did the other king’s soldiers knew where and how to find the mc and that she is the holy being?!

Is this story finished?!

 

Can someone give me a spoiler about Evanna's brothers?

 

Sacrificing my life and my child's life for people who are greedy, worse than monsters, To help a country where the population (both nobles and commoners) thinks they have the right to torture children if it ensures their own safety, while they fanatically rejoice when they torture children. Never!

May that country perish, along with all its inhabitants. I know it's wrong, because the children of those fanatical citizens can't do anything about it. But those children grow up in that religious poison.

They will destroy the guilty (that country with all its citizens, the church, everything that had anything to do with this torture and abuse)?